Tiffany’s Blue Box Café Review: Is Dinner for 2 Worth $330?

I missed four reservation alerts before finally getting a table at Tiffany’s. After all that effort, would the dinner live up to the blue room?

Some restaurants make my list because of a particular dish. This one started with the room.

I wanted to experience that beautiful Tiffany Blue space for myself. Dinner inside Tiffany’s felt like the perfect excuse to do something special for my birthday, and it was another bucket-list restaurant I wanted to check off.

Brittany and I had already celebrated with a very different dinner at Beetle House the night before. This evening was our chance to trade Halloween characters and gothic decor for Tiffany Blue and a fancy dinner.

First, though, I had to get us a reservation.

Short on time? Pin it for later.

Kristen in a red jacket and Brittany in black taking a mirror selfie in the teal mirrored elevator at Tiffany's in New York City

This blog contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As a Lifestyle Ambassador, I may earn a commission if you enroll in Travel Advantage. Read full disclosure here.

Getting a Reservation Took Some Persistence

I watched for openings for weeks, originally hoping to find a lunch reservation for the high tea. I had Resy notifications turned on and received about four alerts for tables within my preferred time range. I missed every one, some by only minutes.

Finally, on the evening of October 11, I checked again and found two available tables. I finally booked a 5:15 p.m. dinner for the following day.

After weeks of checking, we were going to Tiffany’s!

My advice: set your notifications, but keep checking yourself too. That’s what worked for me. It’s no guarantee, but a last-minute opening is how we got in. The café takes reservations exclusively through Resy.

Getting There: Plan for Delays

We took the bus and left with plenty of time, but the Columbus Day parade was on Fifth Avenue, the same avenue as the restaurant, and it delayed our route.

We called three different numbers from the restaurant’s website and Google, and none of them went through, even after several tries. If you’re heading there on a holiday or parade day, check for street closures and leave extra time. Don’t count on being able to reach the host if you run behind.

Thankfully, the host called us and we let her know we on our way. Everything worked out, and we arrived about five minutes late.

The Tiffany Blue Room Was Worth Seeing in Person

Everything was blue-themed and beautiful. It was upscale and refined, but I could relax. Brittany and I could talk easily, and we never felt rushed. Our two-person table had plenty of room for plates and drinks, which I appreciated after our much tighter table at Beetle House. The service was excellent: several people helped us, and everyone was friendly and attentive.

Dining room at the Blue Box Cafe at Tiffany's in New York, with tables set under the Tiffany blue box ceiling installation

As the sun went down, the ambient lighting came on in Tiffany blue, a gorgeous touch that matched the decor.

What We Ordered at Blue Box Café

Everything we ate was delicious and fresh. There were no misses, and I wouldn’t invent a complaint just to make this review sound balanced. One note: the portions are generous, so think about sharing.

Once our orders were taken, bread and this adorable Tiffany & Co. stamped butter was delivered to the table.

Seeded bread roll and a round of Tiffany-stamped butter on a Tiffany plate at the Blue Box Cafe

Appetizer: Crabe & Céleri

We shared the Crabe & Céleri, a jumbo lump crab appetizer. It was a lovely start, and it set the tone: fresh food that held up to the setting.

Crab salad with shaved fennel, grapefruit segments, and edible purple flowers at the Blue Box Cafe

Entrees: Coquille Saint-Jacques & Filet Mignon

I ordered the Coquille Saint-Jacques, the scallop dish, and this is what I’d tell you to order. The scallops were buttery with a light flavor, and the whole plate worked beautifully. The room got me in the door, but the scallops are a very good reason to return.

Seared scallops with charred greens and crispy shallots over a creamy puree at the Blue Box Cafe

Brittany had the filet mignon, which came with potatoes and she added a separate side of jasmine rice. I tried her food too and enjoyed it.

Drinks: Blue Cosmos & Tea

I had two Blue Cosmos. They were good, and yes, I got a nice buzz from the first one. Brittany chose The Phoenix, an oolong tea from the Bellocq tea selection.

Tiffany blue cocktail in a martini glass on a glass table at the Blue Box Cafe

Dessert: Tea Ice Cream & a Birthday Candle

We ordered the Soufflé glacé and the Soft Serve Tea. The soufflé was so yummy and definitely festive.

Frozen souffle with a golden caramelized top in a white ramekin at the Blue Box Cafe

Mine was the tea ice cream. It wasn’t a free birthday dessert, but they dressed it up: it came with marshmallows and syrups on the side to add in, plus a birthday candle and a chocolate that said happy birthday. It was such a cute touch.

One dessert would have been enough. Each could have served two people.

After a delicious dinner and such attentive service, that little birthday moment was a lovely way to finish.

Our Exact Blue Box Café Dinner Cost

Our total was $330.68 for two people, including tax and the tip we left.

ItemPrice
Crabe & Céleri$36.00
Coquille Saint-Jacques$46.00
Filet mignon$55.00
Jasmine rice side$14.00
Two Blue Cosmos$50.00
The Phoenix tea$8.00
Soufflé glacé$19.00
Soft Serve Tea$19.00
Subtotal$247.00
Tax$21.93
Tip we left$61.75
Total$330.68

These prices are from our October 12, 2026 dinner receipt, not a quote for a future visit. Your total will depend on what you order, how much you drink, and your tip.

Where you could save: we each ordered a dessert, but one would have fed both of us. Sharing would have saved $19 before tax and tip.

Check Your Amex Resy Credit Before You Go

Some American Express cards offer statement credits for eligible Resy purchases. The U.S. consumer Amex Platinum offers up to $100 per quarter, with enrollment required. You need to enroll before you pay and use an eligible card on the enrolled account, because a Resy reservation alone doesn’t earn the credit. Blue Box Café’s Resy listing currently shows it as eligible, but check the listing and your card’s terms before you go.

Was Dinner at Tiffany’s Worth It?

For me, yes!

The food was excellent, the scallops were memorable, and everyone was friendly. I finally got to check a bucket-list restaurant off my list, and I specifically wanted dinner in that blue room. If you’re considering spending what we did, ask yourself whether the setting is part of the experience you want. For me, getting it alongside a meal I loved made it worth it.

After dinner we headed to One Times Square, a fun second half of the evening. If you’re planning your own night, leave enough time between reservations to travel comfortably.

I’m glad we went, and I would happily go again.

Blue Box Café Dinner FAQs

Is Blue Box Café worth it for a birthday?

I loved it for mine. The room was beautiful, the service was attentive, and my tea ice cream arrived with a birthday candle and a happy-birthday chocolate. That was my experience; specific birthday touches may vary.

What was the best dish?

The Coquille Saint-Jacques! I told the server I was trying to decide between that and the flounder, but before I could finish that sentence he said the scallops. He was so right!

How much did dinner for two cost?

$330.68, including tax and the tip for a shared crab appetizer, two entrees, an additional side, two cocktails, tea, and two desserts.

Was the atmosphere stuffy?

It was upscale, but comfortable. We could easily talk, had plenty of room, and never felt rushed.

How do you book Blue Box Café?

Reservations are available exclusively through Resy. I found ours the evening before our visit after weeks of watching for openings. www.blueboxcafenyc.com

Planning Your Own NYC Trip?

See how I compared prices on NYC observation decks: Viator vs. my travel membership before you book anything else.

Is dinner at Tiffany’s on your bucket list? Tell me what you’d order in the comments and save this post for your next special occasion in NYC.

Until next time,

Kristen Hebert signature

Sources & Further Reading

Menus, prices, reservation policies, and credit-card benefits may change. Check the official sources before booking.

Portrait of Kristen Hebert, a woman with long dark wavy hair and red lipstick, smiling.

About the Author

I’m a military spouse who’s worn many hats over the years from serving tables in fine dining to management in emergency communications. Between career changes, military moves, and figuring out what the hell I actually want out of life, I’ve learned that just because something is familiar doesn’t mean you have to stick with it.

Here, I share what I’ve learned (and still learning) about traveling smarter, effortless style, making money online, personal growth, and everything in between. My goal is to help you discover options and feel confident enough to explore them for yourself.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply